Smith grew up in Columbus, Ohio and graduated from Hilliard Darby High School in 2005. He had aspirations ranging from becoming a concert pianist to a lawyer. While at Otterbein University, he was cast in such plays as The Scene, The Caucasian Chalk Circle, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, and Tartuffe. He majored in art musical theater and minored in jazz piano, although he considered dropping out of art musical theater for philosophy or pre-law.