In January 2017, Daniel and Sydelko released a parody video of the song "Closer" originally by The Chainsmokers, featuring Halsey. The video prompted a response from Halsey, who criticized the parody and Daniel and Sydelko's supporters.
On August 30, 2017, Elijah Daniel performed a publicity stunt centered around Hell, Michigan – an unincorporated town that allows visitors to pay for the opportunity to hold the title of "mayor" for a day. In what he called "a copy-and-paste of Trump's Muslim ban", he announced a satirical law that banned heterosexuals from entering and living in the town. In response, Daniel released an edited version of The Bible called The Holy Bible... but Gayer two weeks later. Sales of it were briefly banned on Amazon before being restored. On June 17, 2019, Elijah Daniel claimed that he briefly "bought" the incorporated hamlet of Hell, Michigan, changed its name to Gay Hell, Michigan and created a law prohibiting any flag other than pride flags from flying in the town. This was done in retaliation to the Trump administration's ban on the flying of the gay pride flag by U.S. embassies.
In November 2017, Daniel, Christine Sydelko and Tana Mongeau appeared on a segment of The Maury Povich Show in which they pretended to be engaged after Daniel having proposed to Christine at Taco Bell. Christine feared Daniel was cheating on her with Mongeau, but Daniel's lie detector results revealed he was actually cheating with men.
Since 2017, Daniel has been releasing hip hop music under the stage name Lil Phag. He has released two extended plays and one studio album under the moniker, as well as slew of singles with artists including CupcaKke, Bella Thorne, Tana Mongeau, and Dr. Woke, the latter of whom producer most of his music. The pair have since gone on to form their own musical project, Adam&Steve, which has a more EDM sound.
Elijah Daniel and Christine Sydelko jointly won Best Comedian from the Shorty Awards in 2017. Daniel received a positive reception for his comedy posted via video blogging and social media, from Heavy.com, Paper, The Washington Post, and The Daily Dot.