In 2010, Fessenden co-produced Tales from Beyond the Pale, with Glenn McQuaid, a 10-episode audio series now in its fourth season. In 2011, he released his third rock album with the band Just Desserts, an on-going partnership with songwriter Tom Laverack. In 2012, he executive produced and was interviewed in the documentary Birth of the Dead, which examines the legacy of Night of the Living Dead. In 2016, he produced, acted, and served as cinematographer in his son Jack’s feature debut, Stray Bullets. The same year also saw Fessenden release a book titled, Sudden Storm, A Wendigo Reader.

Fessenden has also established a strong presence in the video game world. In 2015, he and Graham Reznick collaborated on writing the video game Until Dawn. Fessenden also played the role of a mysterious stranger armed with a flamethrower in the game itself. The game earned positive reviews and would go on to receive the “Original Property” award in the 2016 BAFTA Games Awards. Fessenden and Reznick also set a Guinness World Record for “Longest script for a graphic adventure videogame,” with their script reaching 1,000 pages. The two writers would team up again in 2016 to develop a spin-off game known as Until Dawn: Rush of Blood, and later in 2018 for the Until Dawn prequel, The Inpatient.