In April 2019, Lyle admitted to punching 63-year-old Juan Ricardo Hernández (of Cuban origin) in the face during a road rage incident in Miami, Florida. The victim was hospitalized and died four days after the attack. Lyle was charged with manslaughter after the elderly man died. He had been originally charged with battery before Hernandez died. There is a video of the road rage incident where Lyle is seen running to punch Hernandez. If convicted of manslaughter, Lyle could face up to 15 years in prison.