On 8 February 2015, Andonovski and Wichita coach Kim Røntved came out of retirement to play against each other for their respective teams for one game.
Andonovski, who became a U.S. citizen in 2015, is a 2008 graduate of Park University with a Bachelor of Arts degree in business administration/management. He earned a Sports Science Masters Degree (MSC) in Coaching Soccer from Ohio University in 2017. Andonovski resides in Kansas City, Missouri, with his wife and their three children Dragana, Luka, and Daria.